UNION- The decision to move the second annual N.J. girls flag football all-star game and the 47th Phil Simms New Jersey North-South All-Star Classic closer together timewise was a seamless and very successful blending of two different games for a wide variety of fans on hand for a fairly cool Sunday afternoon perfect for late springtime football on Alumni Field at Kean University.
“We’re very happy with having both games side by side now,” said Simms Classic Game Director George DiGrande as the highly-competitive and defensive-minded girls flag contest was winding down. “There is a terrific flag all-star game happening right now and then everyone can have a short break before the North-South Classic takes to the field.”
While the North made it two in a row, edging the South, 6-0, in a very defensive-minded Simms girls flag contest, the South snapped a 4-game losing streak against the North with a come-from-behind 19-18 win in 47th Simms Classic to deadlock the series that dates back to 1979 which now stands at 21-21-2.
It had taken the North 45 years to take the lead over the South with last year’s victory, but now the South has rebounded with gusto to tie the highly-competitive annual now pre-summer gridiron battle thanks to posting a late-game touchdown as Rumson-Fair Haven quarterback Owen O’Toole scored on a 1-yard TD plunge with 1:45 remaining in the fourth quarter.
Safety Khajauan ‘Peaky’ Rosenborough of Atlantic City sealed the deal with a big interception to halt any last-ditch effort by the North in the closing seconds.
Speaking of the close contests between the two sides, the North had won the last four games by one point, five, four and two points and the South’s most recent victory before Sunday was in 2018 by the score of 38-16 at Kean.
There were no games played in either 2020 or 2021 due to covid.
Retired Giants great and longtime NFL TV analyst Phil Simms was ever-present during both games and helped get the North-South Classic off to a positive start by meeting the respective captains at midfield for the coin toss.
“Phil has been with the game since 2014 and he is such a valuable part of all the happenings before, during and after the game,” said retired Game Director Ken Trimmer of Caldwell. “It’s always great to see him enjoying being out there on the field with all the kids and he enjoys the girls flag all-star game which continues to grow in interest around the state.”
“We love coming down to see this game every year,” said retired Cedar Grove head coach Ed Sadloch, who still stays busy running Wing-T clinics with coaching colleagues Gerry Gallagher and Don Smolyn. “And, to have one of my former players and coaches Rob Gogerty here to work with the North quarterbacks is tremendous to see.
“It’s been great to see Rob continue the great winning tradition at Cedar Grove where he has had great success with the Panthers!”
Gogerty, who starred at quarterback for Sadloch at Cedar Grove before going on to be a Division I college basketball guard at the University of Maryland Baltimore City, was busy before and during Sunday’s Simms Classic providing pointers and encouragement for North QB LaMorte of West Orange High School who is headed to play his college football at Bucknell University.
And the Gogerty-LaMorte coach and player combo certainly paid big dividends for the North in Sunday’s Simms Classic as the Mountaineers’ senior signal caller tossed a pair of touchdown passes to give the North a temporary lead, 18-13, with 6:18 remaining in the fourth quarter.
He had connected with Union City’s Mark Boyd on a 17-yard toss to pull the North to within 13-12 before a 63-yard bomb to Antoine Blount of Elizabeth provided the lead for four-and-a-half minutes prior to the winning TD run by Rumson-Fair Haven’s O’Toole.
Coaches such as Gogerty, who is Cedar Grove’s head coach and was selected as the 2024 Sideline Chatter Essex County Coach of the Year, it has become very enjoyable to end the school year to return as a member of the North staff in the Simms Classic.
“It is a very exciting opportunity to be coaching in the Simms North-South Classic,” said Gogerty whose Cedar Grove Panthers finished 13-1 last fall while winning a North 2, Group 1 state sectional playoff championship. “I also had the chance in 2021 to coach in this game and I had a blast!
“And, I was able to network and build relationships with colleagues I still talk to today especially during the season while bouncing ideas off of.
“When the opportunity arose again to be a part of this 2025 staff I was humbled and didn’t hesitate to accept it.”
The talent level in the Simms Classic remains at a high level with several future Football Championship Subdivision (FCS, formerly 1-AA) and Division III players participating.
“There are some really good players for both the North and the South, and that has been a consistent part of this game each year, ” said Dave McCarthy, editor of The McCarthy Report college prospect rating service, who helps in the selection of the teams. “They also involve some tremendous coaches and George DiGrande and his staff do a terrific job along with the people from Kean in making this a smooth-running operation each and every year!”
NFL PLAYERS FROM NORTH-SOUTH CLASSIC:
1979 South: Kelly Konstantinos, Highland Regional
1979: South: Jim Jeffcoat, Matawan
1980 South: Irving Fryar, Rancocas Valley
1980 South: Jon Williams, Somerville
1980: South: Robert Turner, Piscataway
1982: North: Troy Stradford, Linden
1983: South: Mike Alexander, Piscataway
1983: South: Dan Zakashefski, Middlesex
1984: North: Craig "Ironhead" Heyward, Passaic
1985: North: Quintus McDonald, Montclair
1985: South Stefan Padfield, Bishop Ahr
1985: South: Horacio Morenta, Pemberton
1985: Tony Siragusa, Brearley
1986: North: Jeff Mills, Montclair
1986: South: Andre Collins, Cinnaminson
1986: South: Ricky Proehl, Hillsborough
1987: South: Vincenzo Inguaggiato, Madison Central
1988: South: Tony Sacca, Delran
1988: South: Mike Devlin, Cherokee
1988: South: Kerry Ferrell, Piscataway
1988: North: Dave Brown, Westfield
1989: South: Alonzo Spellman, Rancocas Valley
1990: South: Keith Elias, Lacey
1990: South: Jay Bellamy, Matawan
1991: South: Bruce Presley, Highland Park
1992: South: Kevin Foley, Cherry Hill East
1993: South: Derek Ward, Kingsway
1993: South: Larry Watkins, Lenape
1994: North: Michael Pringley, Linden
1994: North: Kendall Ogle, Hillside
1995: South: Eric Jones, Hillsborough
1995: North: Roger Chanoine, Linden
1996: South: Robert Sack, Brick Township
1997: South: James Lewis, Piscataway
1997: South: Kareem McKenzie, Willingboro
1998: South: L.J. Smith, Highland Park
1999: South: William Green, Holy Spirit
1999: South: Dan Klecko, Marlboro
2000: South: John Zuidema, Long Branch
NORTH-SOUTH SCOREBOARD
NORTH AND SOUTH TIED AT 21-21-2
2025; South 19 North 18 - at Kean University
2024: North 20, South 18 – at Kean University
2023: North 10, South 6 – at Kean University
2022: North 21, South 16 – at Kean University
2021: No game because of the COVID-19 pandemic
2020: No game because of the COVID-19 pandemic
2019: North 24, South 23 – at Kean University
2018: South 38, North 16 - at Kean University
2017: South 30, North 22 - at Kean University
2016: North 7, South 0 - at Kean University
2015: South 23, North 21 - at Kean University
2014: South 20, North 14 - at Piscataway High School
2013: North 54, South 8 - at Kean University
2012: North 14, South 7 - at Kean University
2011: South 21, North 14 - at Kean University
2010: North 17, South 3 - at Kean University
2009: South 7, North 0 - at Kean University
2008: North 31, South 25 - at Rutgers Stadium
2007: South 14, North 7 - at Rutgers Stadium
2006: North 31, South 16 - at Rutgers Stadium
2005: North 9, South 7 - at Rutgers Stadium
2004: North 26, South 21 - at Rutgers Stadium
2003: South 3, North 0 - at Rutgers Stadium
2002: No game was played at Rutgers
because of inclement weather before kickoff.
2001: North 24, South 0 - at Rutgers Stadium
2000: South 20, North 5 - at Rutgers Stadium
1999: South 22, North 19 - at Rutgers Stadium
1998: North 33, South 31 - at Rutgers Stadium
1997: South 28, North 24 - at The College of New Jersey
1996: South 32, North 23 - at Rutgers Stadium
1995: North 37, South 15 - at Rutgers Stadium
1994: South 21, North 16 - at Trenton State College
1993: South 9, North 8 - at Giants Stadium
1992: North 7, South 7 (tie) - at Giants Stadium
1991: North 26, South 12 - at Giants Stadium
1990: North 14, South 10 - at Rutgers Stadium
1989: South 24, North 0 - at Rutgers Stadium
1988: South 12, North 9 - at Rutgers Stadium
1987: North 21, South 10 - at Rutgers Stadium
1986: North 20, South 17 - at Rutgers Stadium
1985: North 10, South 10 (tie) - at Rutgers Stadium
1984: North 7, South 0 - at Rutgers Stadium
1983: South 41, North 7 - at Rutgers Stadium
1982: South 16, North 7 - at Rutgers Stadium
1981: South 32, North 0 - at Rutgers Stadium
1980: North 13, South 6 - at Rutgers Stadium
1979: South 34, North 13 - at Rutgers Stadium
Follow Sideline Chatter on Twitter @Chattermeister